How to Choose the Right Pre-College Program: 6 Factors Parents Should Consider

Finding the right pre-college summer program for your teen seems easy. That is, until you begin searching. A quick search for "best summer programs for teens" shows hundreds of possibilities ranging from enrichment camps to highly selective academies to colleges that offer summer programs for high schoolers. The problem isn't a lack of summer programs available; it’s finding the best one for your teen.

To compare pre college summer programs, you have to ask the right questions. What does a typical day for a student look like? How much freedom does the program allow? What support is available if a teen feels overwhelmed? Does the experience help students make better decisions about their next educational step?

The answers to those questions will help you distinguish between a program that sounds impressive and one your teen actually benefits from.

In this guide, we’ll walk through six key factors parents should use to compare programs and share a simple scorecard to help you make informed choices.

1. Academic Outcome

When searching for the best summer programs for teens, it’s easy to compare programs by name or prestige. But a more effective approach is to determine what success looks like for your teen, then enroll them in the program that will lead to that success.

The top pre college summer programs are those that help students reach their specific goals. If you can’t explain the outcome in one sentence, the program will be challenging to evaluate.

Here are the most common outcomes (choose one as the primary and the other as the bonus outcome):

• Explore a possible major (try it before committing in college)
• Develop a solid project (portfolio piece, research project, presentation, writing sample)
• Develop fundamental college readiness skills (time management, independence, academic confidence)
• Earn credit (if it’s relevant to your plan, check how it works)
• Find a community (meet peers who share interests and motivation)

2. Program Format

Two programs can cover the same topic but feel totally different depending on the format.

When parents want the best summer programs for their teens, they’re really searching for the best fit, particularly in terms of structure, supervision, or independence.

Choose the format that best matches your teen’s level of readiness:

• Residential (on-campus): For students wanting an authentic college experience, including living in residence halls, a structured schedule, and learning to be independent in a supervised setting.
• Commuter: For students who desire rigorous academics without the “live away from home” shock. It may also be an excellent first step before a future residential program.
• Online: For students who want flexibility, have summer commitments, or would like to learn from home, especially if the course still includes live instruction and collaboration.

3. Student Support and Community Resources

If you’re choosing between two options that both look strong on paper, support and community are often the deciding factors that separate the best summer programs for teens from the rest.

The earlier community integration happens for students, the more successfully they will transition to becoming college students.

The support factor may be what makes the difference between a student succeeding and simply waiting for the program to end. The best summer programs for teens build confidence through challenge and the appropriate support structure, particularly when a student faces new expectations.

You should have a clear understanding of accessibility and health support, such as accommodations and special programs for neurodivergent students, and what will happen if your teen has a personal issue.

Find a program with clear points of contact so your teen knows who to turn to if they’re having issues at school, feeling homesick, anxious, or overwhelmed. Good programs strike a balance between independence and support, rather than leaving students to “figure it out themselves.”

Access to academic support should not be an ‘optional extra.’ Office hours, tutoring, writing help, and feedback become even more critical when the class is fast-paced. Check whether the program is specifically for this age group, rather than a college-class format with no special support.

Finally, don’t overlook the value of a college’s community and wellness programs. Feeling a sense of belonging doesn’t happen right away. Look for programs with cohorts, small-group activities, shared experiences, and ways for students to engage outside of class.

4. Academic Content

Many programs call themselves “rigorous,” but that word can mean anything. The top pre-college summer programs aren’t simply about offering some challenging-sounding course. Look for proof that the academics match your teen’s readiness and goals.

Evaluate colleges that offer summer programs for high schoolers by asking:

• Who teaches the course? Is it taught by college faculty, experienced teachers, or a series of guest lecturers? The best programs are clear about who’s in the classroom and what their role is.
• What is the class size and interaction? Smaller classes generally provide more discussion, feedback, and support.
• How are students assessed? The most effective learning happens when students apply the concepts through labs, workshops, critiques, presentations, or written assignments.
• What is the required skill level? What about the prerequisites? “College-level” doesn’t always mean “advanced.” Some courses are for beginners exploring a subject for the first time. Others build on existing knowledge. Either can be excellent if it's the right choice.
• Is the workload realistic? Even a challenging schedule should be manageable. Understand a typical day’s activities and the extent of out-of-class assignments.

5. Program Options and College Fit

The best summer programs for teens work as a testing ground for the future.

As you compare colleges that offer summer programs for high schoolers, pay attention to how much room there is to find a real program fit. Offering more subjects means selecting one your teen is passionate about or exploring an interest without making a long-term commitment.

When a student is involved in an area they are passionate about, they build a better understanding of what they like and dislike about their college choices.

Checking their program fit also helps your teen have a stronger sense of direction when it’s time to apply to colleges. This can help them choose everything from their college major to a list of potential colleges.

If your teen is undecided, options are even more crucial. Look for a pre-college program that allows students to connect their interests to specific fields of study. That way, the program gets your teen one step closer to making informed decisions about their next step.

“I feel better prepared to put myself out there and to get involved in many different activities in college” —Engineering Design Lab Student, 2020

6. Cost and Value of the Best Summer Programs for Teens

Cost matters, but “cheap vs expensive” isn’t a helpful way to compare the best summer programs for teens. A better question is: Is it clear what we’re paying for? Pricing should be easy to understand and backed up with real value.

Create an accurate estimate of costs. In addition to tuition costs, consider what is included (and what’s not): housing and meals (if it is a residential program), course materials and lab fees, transportation, weekend activities, and any tech requirements.

Two programs may look the same at first glance, but may have hidden costs.

Assess the value of the outcome and the support it provides. The programs available through colleges come with the benefits of qualified faculty, student support services, and an educational experience that feels genuinely “college-level.”

To determine value, look for faculty-led courses and real college settings where students produce work they can actually show. Keep in mind that credit-bearing courses provide even more value.

Lastly, check for financial aid and policy transparency. A reputable online program will have no problem being open and honest about scholarships, policies, and refund or cancellation procedures.

A lack of clarity can leave parents and students guessing, and that’s never a good thing.

Scorecard: Compare the Best Summer Programs for Teens

A simple scorecard can help you compare pre-college programs side by side to help you find the best option for your teen.

Pick your top 3 pre college summer programs options and fill out a scorecard for each. Use the six factors mentioned above to rate each program on a 1–5 scale (1=weak, 5=excellent). Then total your score and compare your options.

Choose the Best College Fit

The best summer programs for teens help your teen explore real interests and make smarter choices about what to pursue in college. Teens can make college decisions with more clarity and confidence.

Tufts Pre-College Programs provide students with a supportive way to explore academic interests, experience college-level learning, and build skills they’ll use long after summer ends. When families choose with intention, summer becomes a meaningful step toward what’s next.

Try Tufts on Your Terms:

Explore Tufts Pre-College Programs